santa hat
deerdeer nosedeer glow
Sign In

Imagine deleting a picture reported for misfiring the NSFW detection instead of fixing the tag

Genius at work.

https://civitai.com/images/3136905?period=AllTime&sort=Newest&view=categories&modelVersionId=165530&modelId=148347&postId=712167

Name me a single thing that fits "illustrated nudity" on this image or warrants removal for any other reason, I dare you. If you feel aroused by it that's a medical condition, not picture's fault. Just because the pixels are generally tinted towards skin colors doesn't mean it's NSFW.

And why do you even set the detection threshold so low? Everybody knows that the proper way to configure any detection algo is to balance the false negatives with false positives. I've yet to see any false negatives on this site, but the positives are all around the place - and this time it's not even an orange tag, but the red one right away. Last time I got an orange for this pic , but at least the tag got fixed upon reporting instead of just conveniently removing the evidence. Yeah, it was when you could still report your own pic instead of having to ask others to do it.

Not to mention that worrying about something so harmless as people posting boobies online is stupid. Nothing bad has ever happened to anyone who saw a pair regardless of their age. Besides we've all seen them when we were much younger, why is it now that you're not allowed to see them again until 18? Admins' childhood trauma?

Let's become the part of the change that needs to happen and stop senseless censorship. Limit the detection to nether regions, it would be a much easier task than trying to figure out whether there's enough clothes on the breasts.

1 Answer

It's a tricky situation. I don't support censorship, or civitai's automatic detection system, but a line has to be drawn in the sand at some point because of laws regarding the depictions of minors. Your deleted image, however, was a mistake on the part of an incompetent moderation team, and triggered by their faulty algorithms; censorship was never a factor. Assign the blame correctly!

Your answer