Sign In
home
models
images
videos
posts
articles
bounties
tools
challenges
events
shop

sampler/scheduler XY Grid for SD 3.5Medium

12
Krawuzzn's Avatar
Krawuzzn
Flux Training Contest Winner
Dec 27, 2024
comparative study
samplersschedulersamplerxy gridxyz grids
sampler/scheduler XY Grid for SD 3.5Medium

Hi friends,

I couldn't find a good comparison of samplers/schedulers for SD3.5M in terms of 'digital painting style', so I created one myself. I think others might find this useful too. Therefore, I would like to share my results

the initial main goal was to find the sweet combination for my 3.5M LORAs - don't intend to advertise them here.

resources & parameter:

Model:

  • Stable Diffusion 3.5 Medium

LORAs: (second grid without LORAs)

positive prompt:

  • viking samurai with blonde braided hair holding a burning flag, sexy cleavage, feminine, epic, rough sketch, yellow and blue, dynamic masterwork by Agnes Cecile

negative prompt:

  • horns, nude, low quality

seed:

  • 696969

triple clip:

  • clip_l, clip_g, t5xxl_fp16

steps:

  • 42

cfg:

  • 6.0

comfyUI

with LORAs: Image posted by Krawuzzn

without LORAs: Image post by Krawuzzn | Civitai

conclusio with LORAs:

aesthetic-wise i would say dpm_2/ddim_uniform is the best result - my personal taste

dpmpp_2s_ancestral/karras was the style i had in my head during writing the prompt for the LORA Test, always worth a try i would say

honorable mention: euler_ancestral/sgm_uniform

conclusio without LORAs:

my favourite image euler_ancestral/sgm_uniform - Jean D'Arc vibes (bad prompt adherence?)

euler_ancestral/normal generating a really clean result (too clean maybe)

dpm_2/simple & deis/karras made cool stuff

overall conclusio:

honestly it's hard to say what i like best, at least i know what combination to avoid :D

SD 3.5 Medium appears highly versatile and valuable in the context of a 'digital painting style,' so I think a workflow with a good mix of different sampler/scheduler combinations and multiple outputs would be a great idea.

give SD 3.5 Medium a try!

EDIT: another Version, without the failing samplers + beta scheduler (with LORAs)

positive prompt:

  • mysterious woman with hat, light shirt, neon pink glasses, punk style, detailed ink painting, minimalist, by Anna Dittmann and Andreas Lie

negative prompt:

  • nude, low quality, boring

Image post by Krawuzzn | Civitai

positive prompt:

  • oil-painting with rough brush strokes on old vintage canvas, old, dusty, scratches, moody, grainy, minimalism, expressionism, surrealism, white silhouette of a geisha wearing a hoodie and porcelain cracked mask with a black raven on her shoulder, bordeaux red and white colors, vintage anime

negative prompt:

  • nude, low quality

Image post by Krawuzzn | Civitai

conclusio addition:

beta seems to be a very nice scheduler. It is very interesting that in all the pictures of the woman with hat, there are big splatters on her face, except for the beta row.

summarized combinations:

  • dpm_2/ddim_uniform 

  • dpm_2/simple 

  • dpmpp_2s_ancestral/karras

  • dpmpp_2s_ancestral/beta

  • euler_ancestral/sgm_uniform

  • euler_ancestral/normal

  • deis/karras

12

Comments